Where Neurologic Diagnostic Expertise Meets Psychiatric Therapeutic Skills

Image courtesy of Flickr user cliff 1066 (creative commons)

Image courtesy of Flickr user cliff 1066 (creative commons)

From the Second International Conference on Psychogenic Movement Disorders and Other Conversion Disorders, Washington:

How do you accurately diagnose and treat a patient with an unusual movement disorder that does not appear to have any objective cause? Neurologists and psychiatrists gathered last week to discuss these and other related disorders at the L’Enfant Plaza Hotel, which is one of the closest hotels to the cherry blossoms at the ongoing National Cherry Blossom Festival.

Psychogenic movement disorders (PMDs) are spectrum conditions featuring abnormal movements that have no known “organic” cause but are not consciously mediated. These movements include tremor, myoclonus, dystonia, paralysis, and paroxysms (see the video on psychogenic nonepileptic seizures). They are thought to be a type of conversion disorder, in which a person’s psychological and emotional reaction is expressed through neurologic symptoms with no identifiable tissue pathology or nerve dysfunction. The movements may be bizarre and exhibit false neurologic signs. They can sometimes occur concomitantly with identifiable organic neurologic disease, including movement disorders, as well as additional psychiatric disturbances. In fact, many patients with PMD have a comorbid psychiatric condition or have a history of traumatic experience in the distant or recent past that may have served as a trigger to initiate the behavior.

No one is sure why individuals express a particular movement and not others, although there is evidence to suggest that some patients, especially adolescents, may unconsciously “model” the movement from examples they have seen in friends or relatives. Unlike movement disorders with objective evidence of disease or injury, these movements may go away with distraction and may be entrained to match the rhythmic movement of another body part or a sound.

Neurologists specializing in movement disorders see these patients most often through referrals, some of whom go on to treat or at least follow-up with patients. Some patients may completely resolve their symptoms, at least in the short-term, with mere suggestion (potentially while under hypnosis) or with a carefully arranged and fully consented placebo treatment. There is no gold-standard treatment, although psychotherapy in its various forms is often prescribed, if it is accepted by the patient.

And that’s the major conundrum that specialists face in diagnosing and treating these patients.  The patients, most of whom are female, may have been seen by many physicians who have been unable to help them or have prescribed inappropriate medications or surgical interventions to improve their condition, often without having first conducted a full differential diagnosis. These patients have often been previously diagnosed with an organic cause to their movements, and may be taken aback when told that their symptoms are psychogenic. That’s why experts agree the presentation of a PMD diagnosis to a patient is critical and must be individually tailored. Of course, neurologists must differentiate patients with a PMD from those with a factitious disorder or those who are malingering.

One of the experts in PMD, Dr. Jon Stone of Western General Hospital, Edinburgh, recently launched a Web site, Functional and Dissociative Neurological Symptoms: a patient’s guide, to help patients and others in understanding the manifestations of symptoms that occur along the spectrum of these conditions.

–Jeff Evans (video courtesy of YouTube user ETPepilepsyvideos)

Bookmark and Share



Filed under Neurology and Neurological Surgery, Psychiatry

2 responses to “Where Neurologic Diagnostic Expertise Meets Psychiatric Therapeutic Skills

  1. Katerina

    Here’s something to stimulate your mind: A new psychological phenomenon has emerged. Cases are seen in something called psychogenic autism (factitious disorders) where the persons either deliberately feign being autistic or they really believe they are autistic. Normally, you find this in people who have taken large amounts of LSD type drugs, combined with a severly abusive past, thus resulting in a very mixed presentation of whatever it is they feel will bring them the most attention and nurturing. Autism is popular today, so many mentally ill persons are adopting this persona. Mainly, because few, if any professionals or media will challenge such a diagnosis after even a less than competant professional duped by the complexity of the presentation—validates it. Ooops, than it becomes a save face issue, where neither the media or the professionals (not to forget publishers who publish stories that later turn out not to be autistic people) involved in the faulty diagnosis want to be embarrassed. This is unfortunate, as this does a great disservice to the autism community in general. Recall the Amanda Baggs controversy and the case of Ms. Donna Williams. You Tube has a recent video out discussing some of this I’ve mentioned. It is on you tube under the name, “autism spectrum seems out of control” and another video named, “autism epidemic out of control.” The video has most definately hit on something few outside psychoanalytical or psychiatric circles, have even noticed

  2. Pingback: sofiaberlanda – Instagram Followers | come-aumentare

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s