American tongues start wagging whenever the latest starlet puts on a few pounds, but we appear loathe to discuss our own ever-increasing waistline.
A study of 453 adults presenting to a Florida ED found that 58.5% of overweight/obese African American and Caucasian men and women feel their weight is not a health issue AND have never discussed their weight with their healthcare provider.
The average BMI in the study was 29.5 kg/m2, mean weight 184 pounds, 61% were female and the average waist circumference an undignified 39.5 inches.
Given those stats, you’d think these patients had gotten an earful from their provider, but not so.
Overall, 38% of all patients reported their weight to be unhealthy, but only 28% recalled being told so by their provider, University of Florida emergency physician Dr. Matthew Ryan reported at the recent meeting of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine in Chicago.
It’s possible that some physicians may be afraid to bring up weight for fear their patients will scurry off to a “kinder, gentler” provider. Others may simply be short on time. Yet even when docs did start the conversation, some patients just couldn’t make the connection between obesity and health risks.
Among patients told by their provider they were overweight, 77% believe their present weight is damaging to their health, yet 23% still believe their weight is not unhealthy.
Dr. Ryan points out there’s an obvious disconnect between patients’ perceptions of their weight and their actual weight and current health, and suggests that “the first line of action toward confronting the mounting obesity epidemic in the U.S. is clear patient-provider education.”
The chaotic environment of the ED may seem like an unlikely place to help increase patient awareness about weight-related medical issues or to provide weight-loss counseling, but there may just be something to the “Willie Sutton rule” that teaches, not just bankrobbers, but medical students to focus on the obvious.
As part of the study, the investigators also measured the prevalence of obese patients presenting to their ED in order to compare it to state and national prevalence rates. It reached a whopping 38%, towering over the already hefty 26.6% obesity rate reported for the general population in Florida in 2010 by the CDC.
To their knowledge, the authors say no studies have directly measured the obesity prevalence in the ED. Thus, the ED population may be poorly represented in existing national healthcare studies, which are largely community-based. Moreover, the obesity prevalence may be higher than indicated by studies like the CDC’s that rely on self-reported height and weight.
Given the author’s findings in the ED, that’s a very real and chilling possibility.
The research was supported by a University of Florida Clinical and Translational Science Institute grant. Dr. Ryan reported having no conflicts of interest.
– Patrice Wendling